Growing up under Israeli occupation, we didn't have much in the way of
entertainment. That's why I watched the Eurovision song contest on TV.
Compared to the usual TV fair on the three available channels, it was
exciting and glamorous. Another reason I watched was to root against the Israeli entry.
Sitting
there in Ramallah, two blocks away from the Israeli occupation army
headquarters and main prison, I was puzzled and mystified why the State
of Israel was allowed to participate in a European song contest. Their
participation would have made sense if the contest were called "Continuing
Tradition: Former and Current Colonial Powers Singing Together." But
how did they convince Europe that they are European too, I wondered. I
concluded that those Europeans were worse at map reading than Americans
and the Palestinian Oslo negotiating team put together.
Or that
Israel is good at propaganda. Really good. They are the masters. I give
them that. Their latest public relations stunt is their entry in the
Eurovision for this year. The Israeli National Broadcasting Authority,
a day after the Israeli army launched its devastating attack on Gaza,
struck artistically by choosing Achinoam Nini and Mira Awad to represent the State.
To
say they "chose" the two women is not totally accurate. Noa was chosen
and she suggested the less-known Awad with whom she's been
collaborating for eight years. The officials saw a great opportunity
there for some serious whitewashing.
The genius of the choice is
that now, in the aftermath of the Gaza attack, we have two women, one
Jewish and one Palestinian, sing together about coexistence and peace
and all those good things. In fact, if you look carefully, you will
notice that the team representing Israel is made up of two Arab women,
for Noa's family is Yemeni.
Furthermore, both are peace
advocates. Noa has previously collaborated with Palestinian singer Reem al Banna. Their entry is called " There Must Be Another Way." It's
sung in Hebrew, Arabic, and English (video). Here's a translation of the Arabic part:
"Your eyes say a day will come
When all the fear will disappear
In your eyes a determination
That we have no choice
But to continue on this road
No matter how long
Because there is no one single address for grief
I call to the horizon
To the stubborn sky." (see here for rest of lyrics)
You
can see how anyone who is not rooting for this collaboration will be
seen as war-loving and nasty. Taking that risk, Palestinian and some
leftist Israeli artists wrote an open letter to Awad, asking her to
withdraw from the competition. This is what they said:
"The
Israeli government is sending the two of you to Moscow as part of its
propaganda machine that is trying to create the appearance of
Jewish-Arab 'coexistence' under which it carries out the daily massacre
of Palestinian civilians.
"Israel would not be able to proceed
with its war crimes without the support of the international community
and the United States and European Union in particular."
"Israel's
image as a 'democratic', 'enlightened' and 'peace loving' state is what
allows the international community to support it. Your participation in
the Eurovision is participation in the Israeli propaganda machine.
"Every
brick in the wall of this phony image allows the Israeli army to throw
10 more tons of explosives and more phosphorus bombs. We are sure that
you also see these images and cry."
They concluded:
"Israeli artists, authors and intellectuals that take part in this
propaganda machine, instead of working for justice, equality and the
upholding of human and civil rights – not to mention international law
– are also partners to the crime. Please Mira, for the children of Gaza
and for the future of every child in this land – Arabs and Jews – don't
be an accomplice to the killing machine."
If nothing else, this
letter and Awad's decision to disregard it, point out to the difficult
position in which Palestinian artists in Israel find themselves. I
don't have any reason to doubt the singers' sincerity when they talk
about the need to further dialogue and that their motives are
honorable. And they have every right to further their own careers. But
I agree with the writers of the letter. Regardless of the intention of
the performers, their act is part of the state's systematic effort to
obscure its violence against Palestinians. And that should be resisted.
The
Israeli song is now a finalist. Although sung by two women peace
advocates, one of whom is Palestinian, and despite its lyrics, it is
not a song of resistance. I will not be rooting for it.
Unless...at
the end of the song, Awad waves a Palestinian flag, or in her
acceptance speech, Noa denounces her government's war crimes.
Now that will be something to watch.
In the meantime, I nominate this as Israel's alternative official entry.